Detail Sander Reviews: Which is the Best Detail Sander?

 

So you’ve got to the point where you are considering owning your own detail sander? Or are you just replacing an old one that has seen better days? Well, either way, you must be quite advanced in your DIY-ing career to be getting into detail sanding! The detail sander category of power tools, as we’re sure you’ve already discovered, has a lot of different makes and models from which to choose from and deciding on the right one for you can be a bit of a nightmare. To make things clearer, one needs to do a little thinking beforehand on what and how often you will be using it for. Is this just for a one-off DIY job or are you planning to use it for a trade of some sort? Are you going to be using it in a place with easy access to power sockets? What about the dust that is generated when sanding, will you have access to a dust extraction system or vacuum cleaner? Are you going to be using it above shoulder height, in which case the weight of it could have more significance? The more thinking you do in advance on exactly how you intend to use it can go a long way into making the job of choosing the best one for you a lot easier.

What to look for in a Detail Sander

Mains-powered or Battery-powered – As with most power tools, deciding on whether to go with the mains-powered, more power, less convenient route as opposed to the battery-powered, more convenient power tool, is always one of those early decisions one has to make that narrows down the field of options and usually makes the final decision easier. In the detail sander arena, the field is dominated by the corded-electric variety, so if you do insist on going the battery route, then your options are decidedly more limited to more well-known brands of power tools. One advantage of many battery-powered systems these days is that, if you stick to one brand for all of your battery-powered tools, you can often subscribe to a system where the battery can be used across a variety of different power tools.

Power – For mains-powered detail sanders, power is usually given in Watts and gives the buyer a good idea of how and what he or she can use the sander on. In the case of battery-powered tools, the battery voltage correlates with the power that the tool can deliver, to put it simply, the more voltage, the more power. A more powerful sander means that it can be used more aggressively to take more material off a surface faster and it also means that it can be used on harder materials more effectively.

Dust extraction system or dust collection box – All materials produce dust when sanded, some more than others, so the system employed to manage that dust is fairly important.  Here one usually has one of two choices, an integral collection system such as a dust collection box with micro-filter, or an external dust extraction system like a vacuum cleaner. Each type has its pros and cons but ultimately, one’s preference usually comes down to how the tool is going to be used. External vacuum systems are much better at preventing dust from getting into the surrounding work environment than dust collection boxes, but then one has to deal with the unwieldy nature of having a vacuum hose attached. If the sander is the corded-electric type this makes it even more inconvenient as the operator also has to pay attention to not tangling up the wire with the vacuum hose as well. In addition, if the detail sander needs to be used in a more difficult-to-access environment, for example, if the operator is perched precariously up a ladder and/or working above shoulder height, then dragging along a vacuum hose (as well as the electric cord) will take away from the ease of use of employing a power sander in the first place.

Weight – The heavier the machine the more fatigue-inducing it will be. If the tool is to be used over shoulder height or for long periods of time, then opting for a lighter detail sander is obviously preferred.

Noise level – Most detail sanders are not quiet machines, but they are not excessively noisy either. Most detail sanders operate in a similar noise range with the exception of some branded tools that have been specifically designed to be quieter.

Add-on accessories – Some detail sanders come with small accessory pads that can be clipped on to the power tool that extend the sanding capabilities of the detail sander. For example, a common accessory is the ‘finger’ attachment that clips on to the front of the detail sander to allow it to reach narrower areas that would otherwise be inaccessible.

Variable speed – This is not an essential feature but does allow the user to remove material from a surface with a greater degree of control. More fragile surfaces may require a gentler sanding action and this can be achieved by slowing down the detail sander using a variable speed control.

Design – For the most part, detail sanders come in two flavours. Firstly, the traditional power tool-like design with an elongated body and a triangular-shaped sanding pad, and secondly, detail sanders that have become more commonly known as the palm sanders since they mostly fit into the palm of the hand. Choosing the type to go for depends on the work one plans to do and individual preference.

 

  
Power source
Power
(Watts)
Sound Power
(dB)
Weight
(kg)
Variable Speed
Add-on Accessories
Power source
Power
(Watts)
Sound Power
(dB)
Weight
(kg)
Variable Speed
Add-on Accessories
VonHaus 180W
Corded-Electric
180W
91 dB
1.5 kg
No
No
Silverline 261345
Corded-Electric
180W
91 dB
1.3 kg
No
No
Einhell TE-DS 20 E
Corded-Electric
200W
84 dB
1.1 kg
Yes
No
FERM DSM1009
Corded-Electric
280W
90 dB
1.7 kg
Yes
No
Bosch PSM 100 A
Corded-Electric
100W
94 dB
0.9 kg
No
No
Bosch PSM 200 AES
Corded-Electric
200W
94 dB
1.4 kg
Yes
Yes
Bosch PSM Primo
Corded-Electric
50W
80 dB
0.6 kg
No
No
Bosch PSM 10.8 LI
Battery
10.8V
80 dB
0.7 kg
No
No
Bosch PSM 18 LI
Battery
18V
80 dB
1.3 kg
No
No
Apollo 180W
Corded-Electric
180W
--
1.2 kg
No
No
Black+Decker KA1000
Corded-Electric
55W
86 dB
0.9 kg
No
Yes
Black+Decker KA161BC
Corded-Electric
55W
79 dB
0.8 kg
No
Yes
VonHaus 130W
Corded-Electric
130W
--
1.3 kg
No
No
Wolf 180W
Corded-Electric
180W
--
--
No
Yes
Ryobi EMS180RV
Corded-Electric
180W
90 dB
1.4 kg
Yes
Yes
Skil 7226AE
Corded-Electric
250W
86 dB
1.3 kg
two speeds
Yes
GMC KAT150B
Corded-Electric
130W
89 dB
1.2 kg
No
No
-- Information Not Available

 

 


Detail Sander Reviews

 

VonHaus and Silverline 180W Detail Sanders

VonHaus 180W Detail Sander

The 180W detail sander under the VonHaus and Silverline brands is a well-built, solid, and powerful detail sander at an excellent price point. Useful for getting into all those nooks and crannies when sanding intricate structures, it is powerful enough to be used on wood, plastic and even metal. It has similar levels of noise and vibration as most other economy detail sanders. Due to its weight and vibration, the tool requires two hands for operation, but the overall grip of the machine is quite comfortable and operators tend to have more control over the machine for more intricate movements than they do with the mouse-shaped palm sanders.

The 180W detail sander has a port on the back of the machine to attach a vacuum, which is essential when sanding particularly ‘dusty’ materials as the dust tends to exit the air vents on the side of the tool straight into the face of the operator if a dust extraction system is not used. Sanding sheets are held on using velcro and are easy to come by, an important consideration since, due to their small size, they are worn down quickly and need replacing on a frequent basis.

Silverline 180W Detail Sander

Of course, one does have to remember that the VonHaus / Silverline 180W detail sander is still a budget power tool, which means that you cannot expect to run the tool for hours on end without regular periods of downtime. Users have reported that overworking the device can lead to it cutting out sometimes permanently due to a burnout and sometimes due to the triggering of an overheat safety-stop mechanism that resets itself once the tool has had a chance to cool down.

With the VonHaus brand, the power sander is usually cheaper, coming with a 2-year warranty, and if buying through Amazon is not sufficient peace-of-mind, then VonHaus also has excellent customer service as well. With Silverline, on the other hand, the warranty period is 3 years, but the tool usually costs slightly more upfront.

 

 

 

 

Einhell Detail Sander TE-DS20E

The Einhell TE-DS20E detail sander is a step above the basic economy brands. Einhell power tools tend to be well-designed, robust and reliable, and this Einhell detail sander is no different. The tool performs admirably, tackling sanding in those hard to reach places easily. Unlike some economy brand detail sanders, vibration from the power tool is minimal, and the device tends to be quieter than its competitors. In addition, it has a rubberised grip and is well-weighted, making the detail sander a joy to use. For a high quality German-branded sander, one might expect that its running costs would be higher, however, it uses generic sanding pads that can be easily sourced from a number of different retailers at very reasonable prices.   Unlike budget competitors, the Einhell TE-DS20E has variable speed control allowing it to handle even the most delicate of sanding jobs. For dust extraction, it uses a vacuum port at the rear of the tool that can be attached to a bespoke dust extraction system or household vacuum cleaner so long as it has the correctly-sized connection on the vacuum hose. Overall, the Einhell TE-DS20E is an excellent buy for the DIYer in the family, and will even stand up to regular use by a trade professional.

 

 

 

FERM Detail Sander DSM1009

The FERM DSM1009 detail sander is another detail sander that is a step above the budget sanders. It does not have the brand-name reputation that comes with other more expensive detail sanders, but it certainly comes with the higher quality and features that are often associated with the bigger brand names.  The FERM detail sander is a powerful machine running a 280W motor, making it relatively heavy and requiring two hands to operate it. However, it is well balanced and with minimal vibration when in use, it can be used for extended periods without muscle-fatigue settling in. The DSM1009 comes with a variable speed control so that more delicate sanding jobs can be tackled at lower oscillation speeds. The quality and features of this detail sander, together with a 3-year manufacturer’s warranty make this detail sander a hard one to beat on overall value for money!

FERM is a dutch company that has grown from a small business started in the 1960’s to a medium-sized company that today sells a range of power tools internationally. Being a European company, the DSM1009 originally came with a two-prong European-style electrical plug which required users to use their own European-to-UK plug adapter as none was shipped with the tool, but more recently the company has started making the detail sander specifically for the UK market with a UK-style plug. However, currently when buying from Amazon, it is a little bit of a lottery as to whether new buyers get the UK version or the European version of the tool as the logistics are worked out.



Palm Sander Reviews

 

The Bosch Detail Sanders

The Bosch detail sanders come in two flavours: mains-powered or battery-operated. Bosch makes two mains-powered detail sanders that are available here in the UK: the Bosch PSM 100 A and the Bosch PSM 200 AES. You will also see kicking around a couple of other mains-powered models like the PSM 80 and the Bosch Primo but these are not official UK-based current models (Bosch has replaced the PSM 80 with the more powerful version, the PSM 100 A, and the Primo was made exclusively for the European mainland, not for the UK) although they are still sold here in this country and can be used on UK mains as well. For its battery-operated sanders, Bosch has fielded two models for the UK market: the PSM 10.8 LI and the PSM 18 LI.

 

Bosch PSM 100 A

As one might expect from Bosch, the PSM 100 A is an impressive detail sander, being very reliable and robust. It is also very easy to work with, fitting perfectly within the hand, and perfectly designed for getting into those tight spaces, nooks and crannies. In fact, for the price, it is hard to believe the quality you get with these Bosch sanders, but there is a method in the madness. Bosch makes its money not so much from the sale of the sanders themselves but by charging more on the sandpapers that these Bosch sanders use. It is not easy to find a cheaper generic brand of sandpaper that will fit these detail sanders, so you are essentially tied into the Bosch brand once you buy them. For this reason, if you have a lot of sanding to do and you are on a strict budget, then these Bosch detail sanders might not be for you. The PSM 100 A and the PSM 200 AES are made more for the DIY-er who wants a professional finish and who only needs to do the occasional sanding job around the home. With the PSM 100 A, users have noted a couple of minor dislikes with the dust collection box: Although the dust collection mechanism does an admirable job, it is not perfect and a lot of dust escapes into the air. However, this is not the fault of the sander as dust collection boxes on all sanders are typically less efficient than external extraction systems. The second issue users have noted is that the dust collection box is difficult to remove and requires a surprisingly large amount of force to do so when it needs to be emptied (which can be quite often if you have a lot of sanding to do!).

 

Bosch PSM 200 AES

With the PSM 200 AES, you get everything you get with its smaller sibling, the PSM 100 A, but you get a much more powerful sander that can tackle more difficult sanding tasks. However, with greater power comes greater responsibility, and in this case, one needs to be careful not to run the sander so long that the sandpaper gets too hot. Several owners have found that prolonged use of the sander can causes the sandpaper to heat up, so much so as to begin to melt the base to which it is attached. Not something you want to see on your brand-new Bosch sander!

 

 

 

 

Bosch PSM 10.8 LI

The PSM 10.8 LI is the first of the battery-powered detail sanders that Bosch offers in the UK. The unit is small and compact, lightweight and easy to use, exactly what one wants in a detail sander. Being battery-powered means there are no cords to get in the way, and it also means that the detail sander can be used anywhere, including in areas where access to mains power is a challenge. For instance, sanding areas above shoulder height is a pleasure with this Bosch detail sander. However, as with all things battery-powered, there is a limit to the length of time one can keep the tool operating for, so for very large sanding jobs, it might be better to go for a mains-powered sander, unless you have some spare charged 10.8V Bosch batteries lying around that you can swap into the device to keep it going. This may not be as unreasonable an idea as it might first might appear. If you are a Bosch aficionado, then you will probably already be aware of Bosch’s universal battery systems, where the same batteries can be used in several different Bosch tools. In the case of the Bosch 10.8 LI, it uses the 10.8V Li-ion battery system.

 

 

Bosch PSM 18 LI

The second of the battery-powered detail sanders from Bosch is the Bosch PSM 18 LI. Once again Bosch has made a powerful little sander that is lightweight and easy on the hands.

The PSM 18 LI can be used with both the dust collection box or with an external dust extraction system like a vacuum cleaner. Since it is already electrically-cordless, using the dust collection box over the external vacuum system is often preferred since it frees the operator from any form of attachment. Indeed, sometimes it is the only way to get certain types of jobs done, like doing sanding work while high up on a ladder.  However, if it is more important to ensure that the majority of dust is captured, then using a dust extraction system can also easily be attached to the device in place of the collection box.

The 18V battery on the PSM 18 LI lasts a couple of hours or so of continual use, but once again, the Bosch PSM 18 LI subscribes to Bosch’s universal battery systems, this time for the 18V battery, which means that the same 18V batteries used across a range of other Bosch 18V Li-ion-powered tools can be swapped in to be used on this detail sander as well. Taking into account its pedigree, the design and the universal battery system, the Bosch PSM 18 LI is considered very good value for money.

 

 

 

 

Black+Decker Mouse Detail Sander KA161BC

The Black+Decker Mouse detail sander is another excellent option for those small difficult-to-access sanding jobs. The unit has been designed to feel just the right size in the hand and is very comfortable to use. The sander is aimed primarily at the DIY-er who needs it for the odd small sanding job around the home. One of the nice features of the small sander is the finger-like attachment that can be inserted into the the front of the sanding pad, extending the reach of the sander so that it can get into even smaller space-restricted areas. Unlike a number of other detail sanders, the Mouse sander has a vacuum port as opposed to a dust collection box. Attaching an external extraction system or vacuum cleaner is always the preferred method for a cleaner work environment, but with a vacuum hose and electrical cord attached it can be a bit of a nightmare to keep all the ‘cords’ tidy, especially if the sander is being used away from the workbench.

As with some other big-brand detail sanders, the Black+Decker Mouse sander requires Black+Decker-branded sandpaper for a correct fitting, however, this premium-brand sandpaper is more expensive than generic brands, and can make running costs considerably higher. As a result, more avid users of the Mouse sander have tended to devise ways of getting around this ‘lock-in’ by cutting generic sanding sheets to the size required by the Mouse and sticking it on to old used Black+Decker sanding sheets with adhesive – a more inconvenient technique but worthwhile if you are working on a tight budget.

One thing to remember with the Black+Decker Mouse sander is that it is designed for small areas of detail work and not for large areas where a bigger sanding tool would be more appropriate. In addition, the Black+Decker-brand is also primarily aimed at light use by a DIY-er and not for professional use. Consequently, some owners who have over-worked the Mouse sander have reported that its motor can fail if over-stressed, sometimes spectacularly!

 

 

 

Vonhaus 130W Detail Palm Sander

As with most generic brands of detail palm sanders, the VonHaus palm sander is primarily designed for light use by the DIY-er and not for the heavy-using trade professional. This Vonhaus detail sander is small and easy on the hands, and can easily be used with just one hand. With its medium-sized 130W motor it is able to handle most low-intensity DIY detail sanding jobs. Noise-wise, it is quite a loud sander but not uncomfortably so. The VonHaus uses a vacuum port for dust extraction, however, the port size is not designed to any standard vacuum hose size so a bit of fiddling and innovation will be needed on the part of the operator to get it to mate successfully with most brands of vacuum cleaner or dust extraction system (although some Dyson vacuum cleaner models have been found to fit). Unlike some of the bigger brand-name sanders, sanding sheets for the Vonhaus detail palm sander are very reasonably priced, so running costs for this power tool will be very low.

 



 

 

 

Wolf 180W Detail Palm Sander

Another day, another economy-brand detail palm sander. As with most Wolf-branded tools, the Wolf palm sander is a robust tool that is built with hard-wearing components, yet at a very economical price. Wolf has also prioritised power on this palm sander with its 180W motor, quite high for this size sander. As a result of these design decisions, the Wolf sander is weightier than other competitor palm sanders but able to handle tougher jobs. Unlike some of its competitors, the Wolf palm sander is more of a multi-sander than a straight detail sander coming with both rectangular and circular sanding base plates that can be used in place of the more common triangular one. Wolf tools are most often sold via the TV’s UK Home Shopping Network, where they sell a wide range of Wolf-branded tools. In general, Wolf tools are robust and inexpensive, with aesthetics tending to take a back seat. In this respect the Wolf detail sander is quite noisy, and the dust extraction system empties into a badly-designed dust bag, which tends to inadvertently come off more easily than a dust box.

 

 

 

 

Skil Multi-Sander 7226AE

You may not have heard of the Skil Tools company, but you have almost certainly heard of Bosch. Well, Skil Tools has just as deep a heritage (albeit American) as Bosch does, with this relatively unknown company dating back to early last century. And if that’s not enough for you, then you may be intrigued to know that Skil Tools has actually been a wholly-owned subsidiary of Bosch since the 1990’s. That is sure to get your attention now!  As a consequence of its pedigree and relative lack of fame, power tools from Skil tend to be of high quality but without the big-brand price tag that would normally be associated with a premium tool.  The Skil 7226AE sander is just such a tool. In fact, the sander is more than just a detail sander, and is appropriately referred to as a ‘Multi-sander’ as the sanding pad can be replaced with various heads, one of which is for detail sanding. The 7226AE is laden with ample power (250W), features and durable components that make it a joy to own and use.

 

 

 

GMC Detail Sander KAT150B

The detail palm sander KAT150B by GMC is another detail sander that fits into the category of budget detail sander as buying one will not likely break the bank. The machine is sturdy, reasonably powerful and fits nicely in the palm of the hand. GMC tools generally do not have the advantage of being a big-name brand but the tools they offer are usually well-designed, robust and very reliable, and at a very reasonable price. The KAT150B is one of those tools and most owners are usually surprised at how good they are.

One niggle with the KAT150B is that it does not come with any option to collect the dust other than via an external dust extraction system. Using a vacuum system is not always convenient in every job situation, and if a vacuum is not available, you will just have to put up with the dusty mess that the KAT150B can create. One final note, although the GMC detail sander comes with a set of starter sanding sheets, when it comes time to buy replacements, double check they are the right size. This is especially true if buying the detail sander from Amazon, where some buyers have reported that some of the ‘add-on purchase’ Amazon suggestions for replacement sanding sheets are not the correct type for the GMC KAT150B.

 

 Posted by at 3:30 pm